| John | Justin R. Overcash |
| Conjur Man | Joseph Rayburn* |
| Dark Witch | Corynne R. Linkous* |
| Fair Witch | Beth Feazell |
| Conjur Woman | Janice A. Laccone |
| Hank Gudger | Chris Cain |
| Edna Summey | Lori E. Spitzer |
| Mr. Summey | Matthew Poferl |
| Mrs. Summey | Amy Cline |
| Miss Metcalf | Meredith Paul |
| Mr. Atkins | Joe B. Stephenson |
| Mrs. Jenkins | Megan E. Demmler |
| Uncle Smelicue | Christopher A. Sloan |
| Floyd Allen | Eric Seelbach |
| Mr. Bergen | Paul Williamson Howle IV* |
| Mrs. Bergen | Laura E. Ellerbeck |
| Burt Dunwitty | Mike Rigoli |
| Greeny Gorman | Becky Lewis-Whitson |
| Hattie Heffner | Penny Patty |
| Marvin Hedgens | Christopher P. Keyser |
| Barbara Allen | Carly Abbott |
| Mrs. Allen | Dana Hunter |
| Mr. Allen | Reid Dougherty |
| Ella Bergen | Carrie Traud |
| Leafy | Mandy Philips |
| Preacher Haggler | Chris Severance* |
| Witch Chorus | Lyndsey Baker, Gina Feazelle, Alayna McIntyre, McKinley Goad, Stacey Horne |
| CREW: | |
| Director | Lisa Warren* |
| Set Design/Technical Director | George Arthur |
| Lighting Design/Technical Consultant | Jon Dorsey |
| Stage Manager | Dan Sciarra |
| ASM | Antonia Samaritano |
| Master Electrician | Amanda Gamari |
| Sound | Joy Daniel* |
| Choreography: | |
| Square Dance | Christopher P. Keyser |
| Witches Dance | Stacey Horne |